Main Office

Oaks Plaza – 14125 NW 80th Ave, Suite 400 – Miami Lakes

(305) 374-1011

weinstein cohen logo

Naples Office

2325 Stanford Court, Naples, Florida 34112

(239) 793-3331

Main Office

Oaks Plaza – 14125 NW 80th Ave, Suite 400 – Miami Lakes

(305) 374-1011

Naples Office

2325 Stanford Court, Naples, Florida 34112

(239) 793-3331

When Your Child Is Hurt in a Crash: How Florida Injury Claims Work

When Your Child Is Hurt in a Crash: How Florida Injury Claims Work

by | 0 comments

Dealing with the many questions that arise after a car accident is difficult. When your child is the one who gets hurt, the questions become much more serious.

Parents who come to our office after a crash involving a child are usually not thinking about a claim. They are thinking about whether the headaches will stop, whether the leg will heal straight, whether the kid who used to be fearless will now be afraid to get in a car. The legal questions come later, often after the family has already heard a lot of bad information.

Here are the parts of a Florida child injury claim that families most often misunderstand.

A Child Cannot Bring the Claim

Minors have no legal capacity to file suit or sign a settlement in Florida. A parent or legal guardian brings the claim on the child’s behalf.

In many cases, that is straightforward. But there are situations where the court will appoint someone to protect the child’s interests such as when one or both of the parents are incapacitated.

Two Claims, Not One

This is an important distinction.

When a child is injured, there are typically two separate claims. The child has a claim for their own injuries, which their parents or legal guardian must bring. However, the parents also have their own claim, in their own right, for their child’s medical and accident-related expenses they have paid or must pay.

The child’s recovery can include pain and suffering, permanent impairment, disfigurement, scarring, and future medical care. The parents’ claim covers expenses they have paid or must pay, along with other losses recognized by law. A single settlement number can obscure those separate interests if you don’t evaluate the claims independently.

Some of the most important parts of a child’s claim are also the hardest to measure early:

Future medical care may be difficult to assess.  A growing body does not finish healing on the insurance company’s schedule. Orthopedic hardware placed in a ten-year-old may need revision surgery at sixteen. Scarring on a young child changes as they grow.  Permanent cognitive impairments will last a lifetime, but how they present may change over time.

Determining a permanent impairment requires knowing what the child’s baseline is going to be, not just what it is today.

Educational and developmental support are especially important with head injuries where there is a traumatic brain injury (TBI). A concussion that resolves on paper can still show up two grades later as a reading or attention problem that wasn’t there before.

Lost earning capacity is real and provable in serious cases, even for a child who has never held a job.

Who Is Responsible

The basic fault analysis is familiar: who ran the light, who was texting, who was impaired, or otherwise caused the crash.

But child cases raise issues that adult cases do not. Were car seats and booster seats in use, did they fail? Were seat belts and restraint systems used, did they perform as expected? When a properly installed, appropriate restraint doesn’t perform as it should, you may have a product claim against the manufacturer alongside the claim against the at-fault driver. That is a different investigation entirely, and it requires preserving the seat and the vehicle before anyone hauls them off to a salvage yard.

One more point that matters in Florida. Our comparative negligence law reduces a claimant’s recovery by their share of fault and bars recovery entirely above fifty percent. Carriers know this and they look for fault everywhere. The law protects very young children. Florida courts have long recognized that a child of tender years is presumed incapable of negligence. Do not let an adjuster suggest that a six-year-old should have been sitting differently.

The Settlement Does Not Just Go to the Parents

Florida takes seriously the idea that a child’s recovery belongs to the child.

Parents or legal guardians may settle their child’s claim up to a statutory threshold without opening a guardianship. Above that amount, a guardianship must be opened for the settlement proceeds and the court must approve the settlement. Judges in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach and Collier County take this obligation seriously, and they should.

Typically, the settlement funds go into a court-monitored restricted account, a guardianship account.  Sometimes a structured settlement is used and the settlement proceeds are paid out over time with interest.  Many families prefer the structure because it can be designed to release money to the minor in installments after the minor becomes an adult.  Otherwise, the restricted account is closed and the funds are paid directly to the minor in a lump sum when they reach the age of majority, which is eighteen in Florida.

For referring counsel: the guardianship piece is where a lot of otherwise well-handled cases slow down. Building it into the plan early is far easier than reverse engineering it later.

The Deadline Question, and the Advice That Gets Families in Trouble

You may read online that in Florida the clock on a child’s injury claim doesn’t start until the child turns eighteen.

That is not what Florida law says, and relying on it can cost a family their case.

Florida’s tolling statute for minors is narrow. The limitations period is tolled for minors in specific circumstances, principally in sexual abuse cases.  For the vast majority of claims in Florida, the deadline for a minor to file a claim is the same as the deadline for an adult. For causes of action accruing after the 2023 reforms, that general period is two years.

Deadlines to file a claim can vary wildly based on the claimant, the type of claim, where the claim occurred, and who the claim is being brought against.  The practical answer is the same one I have given families for more than twenty-five years. Do not calculate deadlines from a blog. Talk to a lawyer immediately after a crash, not months or years. Evidence disappears over time. Vehicles get repaired or junked. Witnesses move. Surveillance video gets overwritten.

What Helps a Child’s Case

Get the child evaluated, and follow through on all recommended treatment. Gaps in care are the single most common thing carriers use to argue a child was not really hurt.

Keep everything in one place. Photos of vehicles, photos of scars and bruising, medical bills, records, imaging, therapy notes, school communications, the pediatrician’s observations.  More information always helps a claim.

Preserve the physical evidence. For example, if your child was in a car seat at the time of crash, preserve the car seat. Take a picture showing it was in the car, properly installed, and in use.  If it failed, take pictures of the failure.  Don’t return it, don’t throw it out, and don’t let the insurer take it.

Document the child, not just the injury. Parents are often the only people who can testify to what changed. The kid who stopped sleeping through the night. The one who quit travel soccer. The one whose grades slipped in the spring after the crash.

And be very careful about the early offer. Carriers move fast on child cases for a reason. An offer that looks generous three weeks after a crash often doesn’t account for a single dollar of the care that child will need in the next ten years.

Talk to Someone Before You Decide Anything

If your child was injured in a crash anywhere in South Florida, the decisions you make in the first few days after the crash will shape what is available to them years from now. You don’t have to make those decisions alone, and you don’t have to make them under pressure from an insurance adjuster.

At Weinstein & Cohen, we combine decades of trial experience with a personal-attention boutique approach to help South Florida families understand what a child’s case is really worth, document it properly, and negotiate from a position the carrier respects. If your child has been injured, please contact us for a free consultation. Visit our website at www.fairnessforall.com or call 305-374-1011 today. Let us help you understand your rights, evaluate your claim, and fight for the compensation and justice your family deserves.

About Author

W&C

Our team has demonstrated the ability to achieve fair and just compensation for our clients . We provide potential clients with verifiable results from a variety of our cases; both large and small but all important to each individual person.